NY man previously pleaded guilty to rape, gets probation instead

Lewiston, New York — Former Lewiston Man Accused of rape and sexual abuse in 2019 He was sentenced to eight years of probation.

News of seven witnesses was in court on Tuesday when 20-year-old Christopher Belter received his decision. Judge Matthew Murphy of Niagara County has given Berter eight years of probation. He must also be registered as a sex offender. He never faces prison time.


Christopher Belter appears in court for a decision.

According to 7 Eyewitness News, court victim Eileen Buckley, a senior reporter, was angry with the judge’s decision.

“Through treatment and remorse, I felt deeply shameful and regretted my actions. No one deserved this situation,” says Belter. “I hope each of you can close the wounds I have torn.”

Berter addressed the court before the rape and sexual assault decisions of four teenage girls.



Christopher Berter is reading from his notes in court.

“But I know there remains a horror that will help remind me of the evil of the night,” Berter read from his memo.

Some of his victims were in court for his decision and learned that he would not serve behind the bar at any time.

Judge Murphy determined that prison time was “inappropriate.”



Judge Matthew Murphy has sentenced Berter to probation only.

“I suffered — it’s not embarrassing to say that I actually prayed for what the proper sentence was in this case, because there was a lot of pain. There was a lot of harm — multiple crimes were committed in this case. “It was,” Judge Murphy explained. “A judgment involving imprisonment or partial imprisonment does not seem appropriate and will be subject to probation.”

The judge has issued a long list of probationary rules for Berter, who currently lives in Lockport. He also received a strict warning about obeying the rules.

“For the next eight years, it’s going to be like a sword hanging on your head,” Judge Murphy said.

Berter also needs to be registered as a sex offender.

He returns to court on December 2 for a sex offender registration law hearing, where it is determined whether it is a level 1, 2, or 3 sex offender.

2018, He was charged when Berter was 17 years old At Lewiston’s home, there was one rape, three rapes, and sexual abuse involving multiple girls aged 15 and 16.

2019, Berter pleaded guilty Two counts: two sexual abuses, three attempted abuses, and three rapes.He received Two-year provisional probation decision.. If he successfully completes probation, he will be given the status of a youthful criminal.

His probation included the following restrictions:

  • Stay in Niagara County
  • Get a job or become a full-time student
  • Live with parents
  • Order of protection by victims
  • No contact with people under the age of 18
  • There is no internet unless permitted by probation
  • No overnight trip
  • No place to visit with minors unless you agree to probation
  • Random polygraph and drug test

“I’m deeply and deeply disappointed. I was hoping for another result today. Justice wasn’t done today,” said lawyer Steve Cohen.



Attorney Steve Cohen represents one of the four victims.

Cohen represents one of the victims and is indignant at the ruling. Cohen states that the “results were zero” for violating previous probation.

“He has privileges. He comes from money. He is white. He was properly sentenced as an adult — it is unreasonable for an adult to escape these crimes,” Cohen said. I did.

Cohen pointed out how difficult it is for clients to hear that Berter has to go to jail.

“I think she’s spitting into the bathroom right now. I’m sorry,” Cohen explained before leaving the court.

Prior to the ruling, Berter’s lawyer, Barry Covert, spoke of his client, saying he was a remorseful young man.
“He is very distressed at what he has done,” said Covert.

During the ruling, prosecutor Peter Widish told a court that called the attacked house a “party house” at a disadvantage to all victims.

“It wasn’t a party house judge. It was a house of sexual assault — that’s what happened there — that’s not something we should have seen in the past,” Wydsh said.

In October, about two months after the decision started, Judge Murphy ruled that Berter would be sentenced to adulthood Rejected the status of a youthful criminal. Judge Murphy said of Berter, “Because it is documented that we did not follow the rules imposed by the court on pornographic abstinence, this defendant may not hesitate to ignore the rules when competing with carnal desires. I understand. ”

“The defendant is making progress, and perhaps if he continues probation and counseling sex offenders for another eight years, the risk of recidivism will disappear,” the judge said in an October ruling. Even after two years of counseling, he posted “above average risk” and re-offended. “

WKBW’s Anthony Reyes and Eileen Buckley first reported this story.

NY man previously pleaded guilty to rape, gets probation instead Source link NY man previously pleaded guilty to rape, gets probation instead

Related Articles

Back to top button